Anniversaries deserve something memorable, meaningful, and beautifully made. If youâre not sure what to choose, youâre not aloneâmany shoppers want to wow their significant other but arenât quite sure where to start. At Hendricksonâs Fine Jewelry, weâve helped thousands of couples in Boise, Meridian, and across the Treasure Valley find the perfect piece. Here are the top five anniversary jewelry gifts that always make an impression, plus simple tips to help you choose with confidence.
How to choose the right piece
- Consider her everyday style:Â Does she prefer classic and minimal, or bold and modern? Peek at her favorite pieces for clues.
- Match the metal:Â Notice if she wears more yellow gold, white gold, rose gold, or platinum.
- Think about lifestyle:Â If sheâs very active or hands-on at work, low-profile settings and durable designs are a smart pick.
- Add meaning:Â Birthstones, engravings, and design details connected to your story make a gift unforgettable.
- Set a budget:Â Great options exist at every price point, from classic gold pieces to diamond-forward designs.
1) Diamond anniversary band
A diamond anniversary band is a timeless way to celebrate your years together. It can be worn on its own, stacked with her engagement ring, or paired with her wedding band for a refreshed look. The sparkle symbolizes the milestones youâve reached and the ones still ahead.
- Styles to consider:Â Classic shared-prong or channel-set bands, elegant eternity bands, or half-eternity designs for comfort and value.
- Gem choices:Â Diamond is traditional, but sapphires, rubies, and emeralds add personal meaning. You can also explore lab-grown diamonds for larger looks within budget.
- Metal options:Â 14K or 18K white, yellow, or rose gold, or platinum for maximum durability.
- Expert tip:Â Bring her engagement ring with you so we can match the metal color and diamond quality for a cohesive set.
At Hendricksonâs, we carry elegant options from designers like Valina, Parade, and Benchmark, and we can tailor a design through Stuller or our in-house custom studio. We also perform fitting and resizing in-house to ensure a perfect, comfortable fit.
2) Meaningful pendant necklace
A pendant necklace is an easy-to-wear gift she can enjoy daily. Whether itâs a diamond solitaire, birthstone, locket, or a delicate initial, a pendant sits close to the heartâmaking it a sentimental favorite.
- Popular choices:Â Diamond solitaire, halo pendant, bezel-set gemstone, initial or monogram, bar pendant with engraving, or a dainty cross or heart.
- Make it personal:Â Add her birthstone, choose the gemstone from the month you were married, or engrave a date, name, or meaningful coordinates with our in-house laser engraving.
- Chain details:Â Lengths of 16â18 inches are most common; choose a sturdier chain for heavier pendants. Royal Chain Group and Quality Gold offer many chain styles and finishes.
With our on-site laser engraving, we can add a sweet message or symbolic detail the same day in many cases, turning a beautiful necklace into a one-of-a-kind keepsake.
3) Tennis bracelet
Graceful, sparkling, and endlessly elegant, the tennis bracelet is a classic anniversary gift that pairs with everything from denim to date-night attire. Its flexible line of diamonds or gemstones glitters with every movement.
- Designs:Â Traditional prong-set diamond lines, bezel-set for a sleek modern look, or alternating gemstone-and-diamond patterns.
- Practical upgrades:Â Look for secure clasps and safety catches. We size and adjust bracelets in-house for comfort and peace of mind.
- Budget-friendly brilliance:Â Choose smaller diamonds for a delicate look, explore lab-grown diamonds for larger carat weight, or opt for sapphire or mixed-gem designs for vibrant color.
We offer tennis bracelets through trusted partners like SDC Creations, Royal, and Quality Gold, with customization available to match her style and wrist size perfectly.
4) Classic diamond studs or hoops
Diamond earrings are a canât-miss anniversary choiceâtimeless, flattering, and incredibly versatile. From everyday diamond studs to elegant hoops, earrings frame the face and elevate any outfit.
- Studs:Â Choose your preferred size, setting (three-prong, four-prong, or bezel), and metal. Add a halo for extra sparkle without jumping in carat size.
- Hoops:Â Petite huggies for subtle shine or larger diamonds-on-the-front designs for major impact.
- Comfort and security:Â Screw-back posts or secure closures are excellent for daily wear. We can check and tighten settings in-house for long-term security.
5) A custom-designed keepsake
When you want something completely unique, a custom design makes the moment unforgettable. Whether youâre redesigning a sentimental heirloom, upgrading her engagement ring with a new halo or band, or creating a fresh piece from scratch, our in-house design and repair team brings your ideas to life.
- Design ideas:Â A two-stone âtoi et moiâ ring symbolizing your partnership, a pendant incorporating childrenâs birthstones, or a band engraved with vows or an anniversary date.
- Heirloom restyle:Â Reuse diamonds or gemstones from family pieces to create a design sheâll wear every day.
- For him:Â Create a custom menâs band with textures, inlays, or meteorite through Lashbrook, Benchmark, or Jewelry Innovations, personalized with laser engraving
We often source mountings and components through Stuller and other top vendors, then finish, set, and engrave everything here in our Garden City shopâso your piece is crafted with care from start to finish.
Bonus: Donât forget him
If youâre celebrating a milestone together, consider a matching gift for him. A new wedding band in yellow or rose gold, an alternative metal style, or an engraved signet adds a meaningful touch. We work with Benchmark, Lashbrook, and Jewelry Innovations to create durable, handsome designs that fit his lifestyle.
Pro tips to make your gift perfect
- Start early for custom work:Â Custom designs, special orders, and restyles can take timeâvisit a few weeks before your anniversary.
- Bring reference pieces:Â Photos or her existing jewelry help us match metal color, design style, and scale.
- Get the size right:Â For rings and bracelets, we can discreetly measure a piece she already wears or resize in-house after gifting.
- Add engraving:Â An inside-joke, initials, or your wedding date, engraved in-house, adds instant meaning.
- Plan the moment:Â Ask us to gift-wrap and include a handwritten noteâsmall details elevate the experience.
Why choose Hendricksonâs Fine Jewelry
Trusted locally since 1985, Hendricksonâs Fine Jewelry has served Boise, Meridian, and the entire Treasure Valley with exceptional craftsmanship and truly personal service. With over 1,000 5-star Google reviews, you can shop with confidence, knowing your gift will be as enduring as your love.
- In-house services: Jewelry repair, custom jewelry design, and laser engraving are all done on-site.
- Curated selection:Â Quality pieces from Valina, Parade, Benchmark, Jewelry Innovations, Lashbrook, Carla Nancy, Royal, SDC Creations, Royal Chain Group, Quality Gold, and Stuller.
- Personal guidance:Â Friendly, knowledgeable jewelers who listen first and help you find the perfect match for your style and budget.
Visit us: 5685 N Glenwood St, Garden City, Idaho. Call: (208) 853-1615.
Whether you choose a classic diamond band, a delicate pendant, a sparkling tennis bracelet, everyday earrings, or a custom-designed treasure, weâll make the process easyâand the result unforgettable. Stop by Hendricksonâs Fine Jewelry and let us help you celebrate your anniversary with a gift that says it all.
References & Further Reading
- Town & Country Magazine. âThe Tennis Bracelet: How a Jewelry Mishap at the 1987 U.S. Open Created a Classic.â Explores how Chris Evertâs diamond bracelet inspired the name and popularity of the tennis bracelet.
- Hannoush Jewelers. âThe Timeless Appeal of Tennis Bracelets: History, Symbolism, and Styles.â Explains the symbolic meaning of the continuous line of gems and why itâs a popular anniversary choice.
- Wikipedia. âEternity Ring.â Provides an overview of the symbolism, materials, and variations of eternity rings, often gifted to mark major anniversaries.
- Lang Antiques. âSymbolism in Jewelry.â Discusses how symbolism in jewelry traces back to ancient adornment practices.
- Barnebys Magazine. âA Brief History of the Necklace.â Useful for contextualizing pendants/necklaces historically.
- Time Magazine. âClassic Anniversary Gifts by Year: History of a Tradition.â Traces historical roots of anniversary gift giving (Rome, medieval Germany).
- Wikipedia: Acrostic ring. Helps explain jewelry that uses gemstones to spell words â a romantic detail you might mention.
